

Ice cream cake is hands down my favorite cake of all time! If you love eating ice cream alongside a slice of cake, why not PUT it right inside?
Combining two of the best desserts into one is surprisingly easy. Here is how I make mine!
Ingredients & Tools
- Your Favorite Cake Mixes: I used two varietiesβYellow Cake Mix for the bottom layer and Butter Golden for the top.
- Your Favorite Ice Cream: My personal go-to is Rocky Road! You can use your Favorite too.
- Cool Whip: I prefer using Cool Whip instead of heavy frostingβitβs lighter, lower in sugar, and tastes amazing with ice cream.
- Colored Decorative Icing & Toppings: Choose whatever fun designs or toppings you like best!
- Baking Pans: One deep, large pan (for the base) and one shallower pan with the same width (for the top layer).
π‘ Pro-Tip: Using two cake mixes will leave you with extra batter! I use the leftover batter to bake a small, regular cake on the side for anyone who prefers cake without ice cream.
You can also make your own cake mix from scratch…
Step-By-Step Instructions
Step 1: Bake the Base Layer

Prepare your bottom cake batter and pour it into your deep baking pan.
Bake until the edges are fully set and firm, but the center is slightly underdone (when you test the middle with a toothpick, it should still have a few crumbs/batter on it).
Step 2: Bake the Top & Prep the Base

Remove the bottom cake from the oven and let it cool completely. (Speed this up by popping it in the fridge!)
While the base is cooling, bake your top layer in the smaller pan. Bake this layer completely until a toothpick inserted in the center comes out clean.
Once the bottom cake is cool, carefully scoop out the middle to create a pocket for the ice cream.
Important: Leave at least a 3-inch border along the sides and a 1-to-2-inch base at the bottom so the ice cream doesn’t leak through!
Fill the hollowed-out pocket with your favorite softened ice cream.
Cover the base layer and place it in the freezer while your top layer finishes baking and cooling.
Step 3: Assemble, Decorate & Enjoy!

Take your frozen bottom layer out of the freezer and gently place the cooled top cake layer right on top to seal the ice cream pocket.
Spread Cool Whip over the entire cake like frosting.
Decorate with colored icing, piping, or your favorite toppings!
Slice, serve, and enjoy!
Storage & Sharing πΈ
Be sure to store any leftovers in the freezer!
If you try this recipe, Iβd love to see how it turned out! Share a photo with me on Facebook @Eljoys expressions.
Thank you so much for reading and supporting my site! If you enjoyed this recipe, please leave a like or comment below! β¨
If you need a cake pan set this one is the coolest and is only $19.99 for a set of 3.. Click the link to get this Great set. Hiware Springform Pan for Baking Set of 3 Non-stick Round Cake Pan Set Includes 3 Pieces 4″ 7″ 9″ Springform Pan.

Express your experience or thoughts about homemade ice cream cake, did you make one yet?
Signup to receive the latest post and pages from Eljoys Expressions π

Leave a Reply