The Lamia Case 2

Benni walked hours before reaching the police department, horrified and concerned for the island’s people.

He ran in yelling for John, “John, John I saw it, I seen the monster.” John rose from his desk, as benni ran into his office saying, “John It’s her, It’s Lamia the demon that feeds on children”

John frowned ” what are you talking about our suspect has only taken pregnant women and the baby fetuses”

Benni pressed on ” yes yes for the younger the better for her but once all the pregnant women are gone she’s going to attack the children. We have to find her and stop her before it’s to late.”

John replied ” that would be great but we’ve been looking for the monster all over the island, so far, nothing. And what makes you think it’s a woman anyway, What happened to you, you look like you were in a Capoeira fight and lost.”

Benni went on and told him what just happened to him, how he’d found a girl, only for her to be dragged off and killed by the Lamia – a beast only he could describe as swiftly deadly and mysteriously terrifying. Then he told John how he saw her and how she looked just like a woman and what she said to him “Once I get my fill of young, I will have you give me one”.


John listened without interrupting, his jaw tightening more with every detail โ€” the girl in the torn dress, the crash, the mangled body in the trees, the voice that had slithered out from behind the tree like it was already inside Benni’s head. By the time Benni finished, John wasn’t looking at him like a man losing his grip on reality anymore. He was looking at him like a man who’d just confirmed something John had feared for a long time and never said out loud.

“Sit down,” John said again, quieter this time. He got up, locked his office door, and pulled the blinds. “What I’m about to show you doesn’t leave this room.”

He crossed to a filing cabinet in the corner, one Benni had never seen him touch in all the years they’d known each other, and pulled out a thick folder held together with a rubber band gone brittle with age. He dropped it on the desk between them.

“Eight months ago I started pulling every unsolved case on this coast that even remotely matched,” John said. “Missing pregnant women, unexplained animal maulings, anything involving disemboweled livestock near the treeline. I didn’t tell anyone because I didn’t have a theory that didn’t sound insane. Until now.”

Benni opened the folder with hands that hadn’t fully stopped shaking. Newspaper clippings, faded incident reports, hand-written notes in John’s own cramped handwriting. The disappearances went back further than the last few months โ€” years further. Clusters of them, spaced unevenly apart, always near the coast, always the same profile of victim.

Near the bottom of the stack was a photograph so old it had gone the color of weak tea. A newspaper clipping, dated almost forty years back. The caption read: Local woman vanishes near Coffee Bay coastline; search called off after three weeks. Below it, a grainy photo of a figure at the edge of the treeline, mid-turn, face blurred by the shutter speed โ€” but even through the blur and the decades, something about the eyes made Benni’s stomach drop.

“She’s not new,” Benni said, barely above a whisper. “She’s been here the whole time.”

John nodded slowly. “And every few years, it goes quiet for a while. Then it starts again.” He tapped the folder. “You want to know what scares me more than the monster? It’s that in thirty years of cases like this, nobody ever stopped it. Not once. Whatever’s happening out there, it’s never lost.”

The words hung in the office, heavier than either of them wanted to admit. Outside, the fog had thickened against the windows, swallowing the streetlights whole, and somewhere beyond the edge of town, in trees that stretched all the way to a dark and hungry coastline, something that used to be a mother was already choosing her next target.

They worked through the night. John brewed a pot of coffee strong enough to strip paint, and the two of them spread the old files across his desk, sorting by date, by location, by cause of death when one was ever officially recorded. Most weren’t. Most cases just โ€” stopped. A woman reported missing, a search organized for a week or two, and then the file closed with a single stamped word: UNRESOLVED, no explanation, no follow-up.

It was Benni who noticed the pattern first, but it was John who noticed the name.

“Wait.” He pulled a report from 1987 out of the stack, an old man’s shaky handwriting describing a “tall, scaled woman” seen dragging something into the treeline near the old lighthouse. The witness was listed as one Elias Mtshali. “I know this guy. Or โ€” I know of him. He still lives out past the lighthouse road. Half the town thinks he’s just the crazy old man who yells at kids to stay out of the woods.”

“Maybe he’s not so crazy,” Benni said.

Elias Mtshali was once a navy pilot who retired to the Coffee Bay coastline with his wife in 1977. His wife went missing in 1980 during a hike in the woods near their home. Elias told the cops his wife had been taken by reptilians, but he was deemed crazy and even suspected of murdering his wife and hiding the body. Now every time he sees someone go near the woods he yells and screams for them to leave and never enter the woods.

They drove out at first light, the fog only just beginning to burn off the hills.

“Guy’s name is Elias Mtshali,” John said, eyes on the winding road. “Used to be navy, I think. Retired out here years back. Half the town thinks he’s just the crazy old man who yells at kids to stay out of the woods โ€” chases off hikers, screams at anyone who gets near the treeline.” He shrugged. “There was something with his wife, way back. Can’t remember the details. Long before my time on the force.”

“What kind of something?”

“Honestly? I don’t know. Nobody really talks about it. Just that after it happened he was never the same.” John glanced over. “Figured you’d get more out of him than I would anyway. You’re the one who speaks his language.”

Elias Mtshali turned out to be a wiry old man with sun-cracked skin and eyes that didn’t waver once when Benni described what he’d seen two nights before. If anything, the old man looked almost relieved.

“Forty years I’ve been waiting for someone to believe me,” Elias said, motioning them inside a house cluttered with newspaper clippings not unlike the ones in John’s folder โ€” except his went back further. Decades further.

He didn’t ease into it. He set two chipped mugs of tea on the table, sat down heavily across from them, and started talking like a man who’d rehearsed it in his head a thousand times and never once gotten to say it out loud.

“I flew for the navy for twenty years. Retired here in ’77 with my wife โ€” we wanted somewhere quiet. Somewhere the world couldn’t find us.” A faint, bitter smile. “Funny thing to want, looking back. In 1980, she went hiking near our home and never came back. Search parties for three weeks. Nothing. Not a shoe, not a scrap of her clothing.” His hands tightened around the mug. “I told the police what I saw the night before she went missing โ€” something in the trees, tall, scaled, eyes that didn’t belong to any animal I’d ever flown over or hunted. They wrote it down as reptilians, same as folks are calling it now. And then they decided the only sane explanation was that I’d done something to her myself and made up a monster to cover it.”

Benni felt his stomach drop. “They suspected you.”

“Interrogated me twice. Never charged me โ€” no body, no evidence, nothing but a scared old fool’s story. But the town decided for themselves anyway. That’s when I started chasing people out of those woods. Wasn’t crazy.” His eyes, wet now, found Benni’s and held them. “I just couldn’t watch it happen to one more family and have nobody believe them either.”

The room was quiet for a long moment. John shifted in his seat, guilt plain on his face for not having known โ€” or not having remembered โ€” any of it.

“Mr. Mtshali,” Benni said carefully, “I believe you. And I think whatever took your wife is the same thing that’s been taking women here for years. I need to know everything you remember.”

Elias nodded slowly, and for the first time in forty years, someone was finally writing it down. As Benni scribbled down every word, John’s phone buzzed in his pocket โ€” a text from his old CIA contact, just three words long: Call me. Now.

Thank you for reading Chapter 2 of The Lamia Case. If you like it, share it, and please leave a comment โ€” or better yet, add to the story. Tell me what you think will, or should, happen next.

Leave a Reply

Published by eljoy

Eleanor Joy happily married and a mother of 3 boys. Currently going to GCU for a Bachelor's degree for Educational studies.

Leave a Reply